About Us



A selection of our favorite desserts and breakfast treats, prepared fresh daily.


Custom Cake Shop

Custom decorated cakes made to order for all of your special occasions.


Consultation & Design

Our sit down consultations feature tasting samples and cake design ideas for your custom cake orders.


Scratch Made

We bake everything from scratch using genuine raw ingredients.


Wholesome Ingredients

We strive to make everything with all natural ingredients.  We also use cage-free eggs, unbleached flour, and organic produce when possible.



For custom orders we offer delivery for an additional fee based on location and travel time.


Vanilla cupcake with topper

Fondant topper on a vanilla buttercream cupcake.


Fondant Flowers

Fondant flowers on top of a vanilla cupcake with strawberry flavored frosting.

Malt Ball cupcake

Chocolate cupcake with malt flavored buttercream frosting.

Cupcake Flight

Try one of each of our delicious custom flavors.

Party Cupcake Platter

Vanilla and Chocolate cupcakes on a party platter.

Tiramasu Almond Cupcake

Tiramasu flavored cupcake with an oren vanilla buttercream.

Mini Cupcake

mini vanilla cupcake with sprinkles.

Muffin Topper

Small vanilla cupcake topper with dragees.



$ 1.50 - 2.50 - Cookies

Classic cookies, bar cookies, and special varieties

  • Traditional cookies like chocolate chip, sugar, and peanut butter

  • Unique cookies like brown butter pecan and burnt orange

  • Brownies and blondies

  • Macarons in a variety of flavors


Tiered Cake2_Blue

$ 2.75 - 3 - Cupcakes

Individual sized butter cakes with swiss meringue buttercream

  • Classic cupcakes like vanilla, chocolate, and red velvet

  • Special flavors like dulce de leche, cookies and cream, and tiramisu

  • Decorative toppers available upon request



$ 1.95 - 2.25 - Breakfast

Muffins, loaves, scones, and more

  • Banana bread and coffee cake by the slice

  • Sweet and savory muffins

  • Cream scones in flavors like chocolate almond and cheddar chive


Tiered Cake2_Green

Price Varies - Custom Cakes

Custom designed cakes for special occasions

  • Single tiers starting at $4 per serving

  • Multiple tiers starting at $5 per serving

  • Delivery available upon request

Custom Cakes


Unique wedding cake ideas on our bakeries pinterest board
Unique cake ideas
People love our Austin bakery on yelp!
People love our Austin bakery on yelp!
Follow our bakery on facebook for up to date cookies, pastries, cupcakes and more.
Follow us on Facebook for the latest updates
Pictures of our cookie, cupcake, scone, macaroon, wedding cake, and more on Instagram.
Find more photos here.

Our Team

Sara Orenstein Mayes - Owner, baker, and cake decorator.

Sara Mayes

Owner, baker, cake decorater.


Not only did the cake and cupcakes turn out beautiful, but they were SO GOOD! Everyone at the party was asking where they were ordered from. I highly recommend My Sweet Austin! You will not be disappointed!


I know that everyone says that their wedding cake was the best, but I truly believe that mine was! The Groom and I threw out some ideas, something nature looking and outdoorsy that also captures our personality. On “the big day” I was more than pleasantly surprised and everyone loved the cake. There were pictures of the cake up on Facebook before anything else at the wedding. Not only was this cake incredibly creative, it was out-of-this-world delicious!